Allah yer7amhom kolhom illi mato fel 7arb fel Iraq w Afghanistan.
I was in 8th grade when the 9/11 attacks occurred. I was 13 years old. My entire adolescence and adulthood have been shaped by the U.S. response to these attacks. However, I was not so young that I did not notice the changes taking place in this country. I grew up with the Arab stereotypes found in Disney’s Aladdin (which I now know is pronounced Ala’ El-Din) and Indiana Jones, so the villainization of Arabs and Muslims in the media was nothing new. But the terrorist attacks seemed to allow people to be more open and direct about their anti-Arab sentiments. At the same time, the U.S. government took the opportunity presented by the 9/11 attacks to break international law, violate human rights, and take away our civil liberties. For the past 10 years, whenever someone has been critical of the invasions of Iraq or Afghanistan, or have criticized the government for racial profiling or human rights abuses, they need only cry “Terrorism!” to justify any and all actions.
For the past 10 years, I have been far more afraid of my own government than I ever was of Osama bin Laden. For the past 10 years, I have mourned the U.S. response to 9/11 more than I have mourned 9/11 itself, for the U.S. response claimed far more lives, violated more human rights, and took away more civil liberties.
Some perspective: According to CNN, 2,973 people were killed in the 9/11 attacks. On the other hand, 919,967 people have been killed in Iraq and Afghanistan since the post-9/11 invasions, and most of them have been civilians. That is about 309 deaths for each 9/11 victim. But of course, when WE do it, it’s not terrorism, it’s Security!
I encourage all of you to read this article by Noam Chomsy, entitled “9/11–was there an alternative?” He reminds us of the so-called “First 9/11″ in 1973 in Chile, “when the US succeeded in its intensive efforts to overthrow the democratic government of Salvador Allende in Chile with a military coup that placed General Pinochet’s brutal regime in office.” This is the 9/11 history that we, as Americans, have not been taught, or purposely overlook. Chomsky and others also point out that the U.S. government did exactly what “the terrorists” wanted: we plunged our country into debt, taking away from social services like education and health care, and aided in the radicalization of Islam and gave credibility to the voices of extremists. The article is a bit long, so I’ll leave you with a couple block quotes:
A number of analysts have observed that although bin Laden was finally killed, he won some major successes in his war against the US. “He repeatedly asserted that the only way to drive the US from the Muslim world and defeat its satraps was by drawing Americans into a series of small but expensive wars that would ultimately bankrupt them,” Eric Margolis writes. “‘Bleeding the US,’ in his words. The United States, first under George W Bush and then Barack Obama, rushed right into bin Laden’s trap … Grotesquely overblown military outlays and debt addiction … may be the most pernicious legacy of the man who thought he could defeat the United States” – particularly when the debt is being cynically exploited by the far right, with the collusion of the Democrat establishment, to undermine what remains of social programs, public education, unions, and, in general, remaining barriers to corporate tyranny.
…
The senior CIA analyst responsible for tracking Osama bin Laden from 1996, Michael Scheuer, wrote shortly after that “bin Laden has been precise in telling America the reasons he is waging war on us. [He] is out to drastically alter US and Western policies toward the Islamic world”, and largely succeeded: “US forces and policies are completing the radicalisation of the Islamic world, something Osama bin Laden has been trying to do with substantial but incomplete success since the early 1990s. As a result, I think it is fair to conclude that the United States of America remains bin Laden’s only indispensable ally.” And arguably remains so, even after his death.
Finally, on the subject of terrorism, I leave you with this video by DAM, a Palestinian hip-hop group. Their song, “Meen Irhabi” (“Who’s the Terrorist?”) challenges imperialist and racist notions of terrorism and terrorists, versus the struggle to survive when your families, homes and cultures are being destroyed.
Peace and love,
Dooler



March 7-11 marks the